Cook’s Illustrated Best Pizza Pans Reviews

If you enjoy cooking and love to make your own pizza, you should think about buying a customized pan or pizza stone. This is essential to make a fantastic crust. With the best pizza pan, you can expand your culinary skills and bake the perfect crust. You can even do thin or deep dish. The possibilities are endless.

Pizza stones are the traditional way to make your own crust, it is how the Italians do it after all. The stone can get up to 900 degrees when cooked in a conventional oven. Your home oven will be slightly cooler than that but you can still make an amazing crust in the comfort of your own home. A pizza stone is usually made of ceramic, the reason for this is so they heat up a little bit at a time and then retain their heat. This method allows a pizza crust to cook slowly and evenly. The result is an incredibly crunchy crust.

Another way to make an amazing pizza crust is by baking it in a metal pan. These pizza pans are good if you don’t want to shell out the money for a stone but they can make the crust a little soft. You won’t get the same crunch from a pizza pan versus a stone.

Best Pizza Pan

To make an amazing pizza, you don’t need a pizza oven or even a pizza stone, in fact, the majority of those who cook at home use the metal type pizza pan because they’re more available and easier to cook in your home oven. The following article will review the best pizza pan overall that you can buy today. The metal pans are the best option since they are easy to use and maintain. A homemade pizza usually requires a high heat when cooking, but when you’re using a metal pizza pan, you can counter the heat with the pan itself. Slow cooking may also be required to cook a crust properly. We’ve compiled this list of top 5 best pizza pan for you, and you can choose one of them to make your cook much easier.

1. Lodge Pro-Logic P14P3 Cast Iron Pizza Pan

The Lodge Cast Iron Pizza pan is simple yet effective when it comes to baking pizza crust at home. Made of cast iron, the pan is perfect for creating a crunchy, perfect, thin-crust. It is perhaps the best pizza pan on the list. The cast iron pizza pan is not dish washer safe though, you need to wash it by hand.

2. T-Fal AirBake Nonstick Pizza Pan

The T-Fal AirBake Ultra Insulated Nonstick Perforated Pizza Pan has air flow technology that allows the pizza crust to cook on all sides. It also keeps the crust from being too soft or moist so you’ll have the perfect pizza, every time. There are also cool touch handles for easy handling. The pan is easy to clean and is non-stick for easy transfer of the pizza to your plate.

3. Calphalon Nonstick Bakeware, Mini Pizza Pan, 7-inch

The Simply Calphalon Nonstick Bakeware 4 Piece Mini Pizza Pan Set is a twist on your traditional pizza pan in that you can make smaller personal pizzas. The pan makes four small pizzas and they are great! The non-stick pizza pan has airflow holes to keep the crusts crunchy. They’re oven safe and are easy to clean. The pan is also safe to put into the dishwasher.

4. Chicago Metallic Non Stick 14-Inch Perforated Pizza Crisper

A high quality metal pizza pan, the Chicago Metallic Non-Stick Perforated Pizza Crisper is the one to buy if you like crunchy, crispy pizza crust. This is the perfect pan if you like a thin crust pizza. The pan is easy to clean with a non-stick surface. It is also dishwasher safe and durable. If you like a crispy, thin crust pizza, this is the pan for you.

5. Oneida Commercial 16 Inch Pizza Pan

A steel pizza pan that holds up to the rigors of daily use, the Oneida Commercial Bakeware Round Pizza Pan makes an amazing, crunchy pizza crust in the comfort of your own home. The pan has holes to allow for airflow and a non-stick coating. It is made to last and you’ll get years of home cooking out of this pan. It is also easy to clean and dishwasher safe.

Best Deep Dish Pizza Pan

If you’re a fan of deep dish pizza, you may be surprised to find out that you can make it right in your own kitchen. In fact, it can be as easy as buying a pizza pan to bake right in your oven. The best deep dish pizza pan have deep sides to create that thick crust you love. The pans are made this way so you can add as many toppings as you like. Deep dish pizza pans can be made out of metal or stone, much like a regular pizza stone. These pans allow you to cook a pizza by cooking the crust evenly. The best deep dish pans are also easy to clean, since you’ll have a lot of cheese on your pizza that can stick to the sides. All of the pans reviewed here are high quality and made to last, they are durable and will handle daily baking.

1. SuperStone / 13″ Deep-Dish Non-Stick Pizza Stone

This best pizza maker is simply the best deep dish you can buy. It is made of stone and that helps the pizza cook evenly. It really is the best way to make a deep dish pizza, combining a crunchy crust with the right amount of softness. The dish is made well and also easy to clean with a non-stick coating. The dish is easy to handle too with ridges that make it easy to hold when removing from the oven.

2. Pizzacraft PC0302 9.75″ Round Porcelain-Coated Deep Dish Pizza Pan

This best pizza pan is a durable, quality deep dish pan made from porcelain. It’s a smaller deep dish pan but it is also very deep, that means you can pile on the topping and cheese! The non-stick pan transfers heat evenly and cooks through and through for an amazing, crunchy crust you’ll love.

3. Chicago Metallic Non Stick 14-Inch Deep Dish Pizza Pan

The Chicago Metallic Non Stick 14-Inch Deep Dish Pizza Pan is another great pick for deep dish pizza pans, this is because it is a bigger pan but also very deep. The pan is metallic and allows for consistent transfer of heat for even cooking. It means your pizza will cook with a golden crust and make it crispy all the way around. It has a non-stick coating so you can transfer the pizza easily. If you love a nice deep dish pizza, try this pan to bring the deep dish home.

4. USA Pan Bakeware Aluminized Steel 14 x 1.5 Inch Deep Dish Hard Anodized Pizza Pan

This Pizza Pan is a large deep dish pizza pan that is durable and easy to clean. The pan is made of steel and it will handle the rigors of daily use. It’s over an inch deep to handle a lot of toppings and cheese. You’ll love the crispy crust you get out of this pan.

5. Nordic Ware Natural Aluminum Commercial Deep Dish Pizza Pan

The NordicWare Naturals 14 inch Deep Dish Pizza Pan is a larger deep dish pan made to bake a larger deep dish crust. It is made of metal and is made to last. The pan is deep enough for a large variety of toppings. It is a quality pizza pan that makes a consistent, crunchy crust every time. You won’t be disappointed in this selection, especially if you like a larger deep dish pizza.